All of them, those in power, and those who want the power, would pamper us, if we agreed to overlook their crookedness by wilfully restricting our activities.
Disclaimer: Dianetics and Scientology are trademarks of the Religious Technology Center (RTC.) These pages and their author are not connected with the Church of Scientology or RTC, or any other organization residing under their corporate umbrella.
This site is best viewed using a highly standards-compliant browser
"THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN CONTROL PEOPLE IS TO LIE TO THEM." —
L. Ron Hubbard, "Off the
Time Track," lecture of June 1952
"The student should be coached on a gradient until he/she can lie
facily." — L. Ron Hubbard,
"TR-L"
|
"The evidence portrays a man who has been virtually a pathological
liar when it comes to his history, background and achievements."
— Judge Paul G. Breckenridge, Jr. on Hubbard in "Scientology
v. Armstrong", 1984.
|
TR-L:
(Training Routine: Lying)
Training Stress: In Part 1 coach gives command, student
originates a falsehood. Coach flunks for out TR 1
or TR 0. In Part 2 coach asks questions of the student
on his background or a subject. Student gives untrue
data of a plausible sort that the student backs up with
further explanatory data upon the coach's further questions.
The coach flunks for out TR 0 and TR 1, and for student
fumbling on question answers. The
student should be coached on a gradient until he/she can
lie facily.
Channel 4 (UK, 1997): "Secret Lives - L. Ron Hubbard" @ Xenu TV
HUBBARD IN 1968: "By 1948, through my own processing, and use of the principles I had isolated up to that time, was able to pass a 100% combat physical, which was very mysterious to the government, how had I suddenly become completely physically well, from being blind and lame." It was an odd story, because Hubbard's war record shows his recurring problem was a stomach ulcer. There are mentions of conjunctivitis, but none of blindness. Indeed, none of his navy medical reports, before, during, or after the war, contain any suggestion of blindness, only short-sightedness and astigmatism.
ITV (England, 1996): "The Big Story - The S Files" @ Xenu TV If targets had no ready cash or property to sell they'd be persuaded to take out a loan. To make borrowing easy the [Scientology] Registrars kept a handy stock of forms from all the major financial lending institutions. They then persuaded people to lie to the bank about the purpose of the loans. This constitutes criminal deception. [...] Solitary Tree: "Lying as Religious Rite"
In a
1992 Canadian court case, the defense lawyer (representing
the Church of Scientology!) said that the prosecution witnesses
[Scientologists] could not be believed, because they had
all taken special training in how to lie.
Caroline Letkeman: "Fraudulent Claims About L. Ron Hubbard"
By the end of my first day in Scientology, at the Vancouver,
B.C. org, I knew that the source of the Dianetics and Scientology
sciences was Lafayette Ronald Hubbard, whom the Scientologists
called Ron or LRH. Brilliant and prolific writer,
nuclear physicist, engineer and mathematician, who was crippled
and blinded in World War II and cured himself with his modern
mental technology. The org had all sorts of biographies
of L. Ron Hubbard in handouts and books listing the academic
degrees, credentials and accomplishments of this amazing
man of science. As a nineteen year old country girl,
whose choice of profession was to write, I was deeply impressed.
Following is a list of documents demonstrating that Hubbard consistently misrepresented himself as a researcher, engineer, nuclear physicist, doctor, etc. Tampa Org: Scientology Promo Flyer
This
flyer, distributed in Tampa, Florida in summer 2005, is
quite possibly the worst bit of promotion the Scientology
cult has produced in the past ten years. It repeats many
of the old lies that have already been thoroughly debunked,
e.g., that cult founder L. Ron Hubbard
was a nuclear physicist and understood higher mathematics
(he flunked out of college in his sophmore year),
that he conducted "research" at George Washington University,
that he was a civil engineer (CE), etc. All false. And who
the hell was "Sir Gams Jeans"??? What's clear from this
flyer is the strong streak of anti-intellectualism that
pervades Scientological thinking.
[Addendum to the above: L. Ron Hubbard's transcript from George Washington University] The Fishman affidavit - Exhibit b: On control and lying
THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN CONTROL PEOPLE IS TO LIE TO THEM.
You can write that down in your book in great big letters.
The only way you can control anybody is to lie to them.
Barbara Graham: Scientology at Ground Zero
Intercepted emails from Scientologists in New York City
are revealing, it shows that this group is intentionally
using deceit to gain access to the vulnerable people still
suffering from shock and grief. Moreover, it has deliberately
interfered with legitimate mental health practitioners sent
there to assist. Below are a few excerpts from these emails,
sent out to Scientologists to promote this parasitic behavior
by "Lt." Simon Hare, CO, I HELP Canada (in NY). (Note: the
"Lieutenant" designates a rank in the
Sea Org, not
to be confused with actual military rank)
Carroll Star News (2002): "The 'P' Stands for Prima Donna"
We've now been visited on several occasions by both
representatives of Narconon and the Scientologists, and
I wish each and every one of you reading this could have
been present at these meetings. In fact, I'm glad that
Sue Horn and Brian Crotty were there with me, because
otherwise I might be afraid no one might believe their
unfathomable dishonesty. They were
caught in lie after lie after lie, and when confronted
with the truth, they opted to lie more. I think
what galled us all the most wasn't so much that they
chose to lie so much, but that they thought so little of
our intelligence that they genuinely believed that we
would swallow the garbage they were trying to feed us.
It got so hard to take that I forcibly terminated our
meeting (in true Mike Wallace style) with Susan Webb.
There was no point in going on. Her purpose - proving
herself a liar - had been fulfilled.
The "Proceedings..." caption implies that this eight page
paper was actually published in the conference proceedings.
The problem is that there is no published proceedings
for this conference! Two employees at the
American Public Health Association
confirmed that the only submissions to this meeting are
250 word abstracts, and the abstract is the only thing printed
and distributed to attendees.
So not only was this paper not peer reviewed (no one at APHA laid eyes on it), it wasn't even published! At least not by APHA, as the caption claims. Once again, Narconon proves themselves to be liars and frauds. The Big Lie: "Education Alive has trained 20,000 teachers"
Jon Atack: "Scientology, Dianetics and L. Ron Hubbard: The Total Freedom Trap"
Hubbard completed this "shakedown cruise" by firing on a
fortunately uninhabited Mexican island. He was removed from
command, and Rear Admiral Braisted wrote in a fitness report,
"Consider this officer lacking in the essential qualities
of judgment, leadership and cooperation. He acts without
forethought as to probable results ... Not considered qualified
for command or promotion at this time. Recommend duty on
a large vessel where he can be properly supervised."
The advice was followed, and Hubbard served briefly as a navigation officer aboard the USS Algol, before its departure from U.S. waters. Hubbard was one of hundreds of officers transferred to the School of Military Government on the Campus of Princeton University. This was to lead to Hubbard's later and completely false boast to have graduated from Princeton. In a more candid moment, Hubbard said that he "flunked" his overseas examination. The San Diego Union-Tribune (1990): Hubbard Hot-Author Status Called Illusion
The book's sudden success, say dozens of former Scientologists
and book dealers, was the result of
a church plan to create the illusion
of L. Ron Hubbard as a hot author. The church, they
say, sustains the myth - 15 New York Times best sellers
and counting - through dubious marketing tactics and the
manipulation of an obedient flock of consumers.
In 1986 the Federal Court of Appeals in Boston said
evidence in an extortion case indicated
that Scientology investigators had induced witnesses to
lie. It identified one investigator as
Eugene M. Ingram.
Eight years later, Ingram was charged with impersonating a police officer in seeking information about a sheriff in Tampa, Fla., while working as a church investigator. He and a Scientology employee flashed badges and told a woman that they were police detectives before questioning her about possible links between a county sheriff and what was said to be a prostitution ring, police records say. Dagbladet: "False interview published all over the world"
- The Norwegian Defense Minister is going to distribute
the book The Way To Happiness to all Norwegian soldiers,
it says in the sect newspaper Good News, which is
distributed all over the world.
- Babble, says Jorgen Kosmo about the "interview" with him in the Scientology newspaper. [picture of Defense Minister below] "FABRICATED: - I never read the book. I don't like this church, says Jorgen Kosmo"Willamette Week (1985): "Scientology on trial"
Samuels described in detail the special
areas in which Scientology witnesses were coached
to lie. He admitted to having committed perjury
himself at that trial, and described numerous instances
of perjured testimony by others. Asked to explain the widespread
use of deceit within the organization, other former Scientologists
who testified in the more recent trial gave similar responses.
Former Executive Director International Bill Franks put
it this way: "I was giving acceptable truth. In Scientology
that is how we are trained to talk."
stop-narconon.org: "Narconon Uses Fraudulent Endorsements"
[...] Narconon's falsely associating me with their scam
has harmed my professional reputation and injured my good
name. I demand that my name be removed immediately from
these web pages, as I want nothing to do with Narconon or
Scientology. I'm 74 years old and don't have time for science
fiction.
Dr. Norma S. Tigerman Boston Herald (1998): "Judge Found Hubbard lied about achievements" by Joseph Mallia
But some of those words are a legacy of exaggerations, half-truths
and outright lies, according to Hubbard's son, court records
and critics.
"The organization clearly is schizophrenic and paranoid, and this bizarre combination seems to be reflective of its founder LRH," wrote California Superior Court Judge Paul Breckenridge during a top Scientology defector's court suit against the church. [...] The Guardian (Feb. 1980): "Scientology's bizarre manual of dirty tricks"
The ruthless attitude of the Church of Scientology in dealing
with its critics is confirmed and detailed by other Washington
documents.
A memorandum dated March 9, 1970, addressed to the "Guardian World Wide," Jane Kember — the cult's senior administrative executive, who is based at East Grinstead — gives a "list" of "the successful and unsuccessful actions used by (Scientology) intelligence." Successful actions include: 1. The use of false letterheads to gather information.
Tory Christman is interviewed for this San Diego news segment.
Scientologist David Meyer promotes Scientology and claims
he's never read the OT III material concerning Xenu, yet
Scientology's own publications show that
he has indeed done so. Why does Scientology refuse to
tell the truth?
Dennis Erlich: "Greetings from a Survivor / End of the Q."
All staff and students were told exactly
what lie to tell any Clearwater residents who asked about
our presence: we were all religious students
on retreat at the new United Churches facility in the Fort
Harrison Hotel.
The Church routinely claims that the
bill was defeated through the efforts of Scientologists.[23]
However, as already noted, the bill passed, albeit minus
the reciprocal commitment provisions — it was not in any
way "defeated". The Church's claims
to have led the campaign are also not supported by the contemporary
evidence. The
Congressional Record's account of the Senate hearings
into the bill does not mention the Church, and a contemporary
review of the opposition to the bill likewise attributes
the lead role elsewhere:
I would say that 99 per cent of what my father has written
about his own life is false. — L. Ron Hubbard Jr.
The Guardian (UK, 2003): "Cult church censured on drug ads" by Stephen Bates
A Church of England spokesman said: "The
truth is Scientology makes claims for their dangerous cult
which they can neither prove nor substantiate. Drug
users trying to kick the habit are vulnerable. This makes
them perfect prey for cults."
|
Dallas News (Oct. 2007): "Bogus Scientology pamphlets irk
Dallas mayor" by Rudolph Bush
The booklet, so titled and featuring the writings of Church
of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, was sent to the
mayor's office complete with the city of Dallas seal and a
ringing endorsement purportedly from Mr. Leppert.
The front cover features a painting of a grassy field sweeping toward the Dallas skyline with the city's official "D" symbol hovering in the foreground. "Presented by Office of the Mayor," it states. But the booklet didn't come from the mayor, and no one at the city has anything to do with it. [...] Another fake endorsement in San Francisco: San Francisco Chronicle (Oct, 2007): "Group censured for using Newsom's image in pro-Scientology booklet" Radar (Apr. 24, 2007): "Slinging Scientology, Mud on VT Campus" by John Cook
The e-mail, posted by an alert Radar reader in our
Comments section, also claimed that the Salvation Army had
urgently sought the help of L. Ron's kids: "We have been asked by the Salvation Army staff
... to provide 24-hour help for the next two days in the
form of grief counseling and trauma relief for the parents
and families of the victims."
The Citizen Commission
on Human Rights caught lyingWell, not quite. Mark McNamee, the provost of Virginia Tech (who, despite being referred to as a "her" in the e-mail, is a dude) made no such request, according to the university. "No administrator invited the Church of Scientology or any other group to campus," says Kerstin Roan of Virginia Tech's public relations department, adding that in the chaos following the shootings, anyone offering help was "welcomed with open arms." [...]
The
Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) falsely claimed
that its touring exhibit, "Psychiatry:
Industry of Death", was co-sponsored by
Howard University,
and when the lie was
spotted
by an astute reader, the
evidence for this lie was (tentatively) removed from
the web.
CBC (Nov. 1985): "The Fifth Estate - Scientology"
Nan McLean: I did a lot of things for Scientology. I broke the law for instance for Scientology. Hana Gartner: How did you break the law? Nan McLean: I was ordered to go to a bank and falsify my income, falsify my employer in order that I would be acceptable as a guarantor for two separate Scientologists' loans. I signed my name to that falsification of records. And the loan was granted, the Scientologists. Hana Gartner (voice over): What troubles Nan McLean more than anything is that she brought her husband, two sons and a daughter in law into the Church with her. Nan McLean: My daughter will tell you a very interesting thing she told me, she is the one and only that didn't come in. She said "Mother, I have always known you to be the most honest person I have ever known, and now you're telling me it's ok to lie for Scientology." That's when a began to look. God that still hurts. [...]
TWTH, Downing told the Pasadena Weekly, also apparently
fraudulently posted on the Web a letter of commendation
from the LAPD that was not signed by alleged writer Chief
William Bratton, and also forged Downing's
approval by rubber-stamping his signature to the
image on the site, www.twth.org But that isn't the only
time TWTH, which has distributed booklets to more than 12
million American schoolchildren in 12,600 public schools
since its inception in 1984, allegedly fabricated information
to promote its product.
Toronto Globe and Mail: "Cult harassment, spying in Canada documented" by John Marshall
Scientology's Funny Photos - Washington Post Reliable Source Column (also ZDNet's "Scientologists admit to altering New Year photos")
Affidavit of Howard "Homer" Schomer (18 March 1986)
22. While on board the Apollo and later in Clearwater,
we were trained to lie to customs and government officials.
I had first-hand knowledge of this because one of my positions
aboard the Apollo from March 1974 to November 1975 was as
the equipment, road manager and advance man for the "Apollo
Troupe Org" which was an entertainment group, [handwritten:
and I dealt first hand with them.]
Affidavit of Vicki Aznaran (29 June 1993) 9. Attached as Exhibit "B" to this declaration
is a true copy of a document called "TR L", which is a
Scientology training drill to teach Scientologists to
lie convincingly
Affidavit of Margery Wakefield (23 June 1993) 8. I remember asking one of the
G.O. staff members
about the fact that they were teaching me to lie under oath,
and I was quoted the Scientology policy called "the greatest
good for the greatest number of dynamics," which simply
means that whatever must be done to ensure the survival
of the "third dynamic of Scientology" must be done regardless
of the side effects. In other words, Scientology law is
considered to be above and outside the jurisdiction of non-Scientology
or "wog" law. Scientologists do not honor the Biblical oath,
even though they may say that they do. This is TR-L in practice.
[...]
18. I believe that most any ordinary Scientologist who was trained in Training Routine Lie would, upon command, lie in court, and would lie also about having been so trained. To put it simply, nothing such a Scientologist says in court can be believed or regarded to be true, as the Scientologist believes him or herself to be above, or outside the jurisdiction of "wog law." Such a Scientologist will not honor the Biblical oath because it has no meaning to him/her. Declaration of Jonathan Caven-Atack (9 April 1995)
Affidavit of William Franks (3 April 1985)
16. While I was Executive Director of the Church of Scientology,
we continually attempted to shield L. Ron Hubbard from any
legal liability as a result of Church of Scientology activities.
To do this, we continually lied in
sworn affidavits and depositions about our contacts with
L. Ron Hubbard, his control of the Church of Scientology,
and our knowledge of his whereabouts. These perjurious statements
were intentionally and willfully made, with the knowledge
of Hubbard himself. In fact, he ordered many of the statements
to be made.
Clearwater Sun: "Witnesses Tell of Break-ins, Conspiracy" by Steven Girardi
She said she was taught to "handle" the press, FBI raids
and knew of "tell a lie" drills which taught guardian agents
to successfully lie about activities if ever questioned.
Affidavit of Ronald DeWolf a/k/a L. Ron Hubbard, Jr. (circa 1982)
Throughout the development years of Scientology and to the
present date, the Church of Scientology has made the foregoing
representations and most individuals who have joined the
organization that I personally know, relied specifically
on my father's represented qualifications and credentials.
The stated representations are all
false. He never obtained degrees from those universities,
or ever served in
combat. He was relieved of duty three times as being
unfit, and ended up in a psychiatric hospital at the end
of the war. He is a fraud and has always been a fraud.
Affidavit of Andre Tabayoyon (5 March 1994)
54. The function of the guards is not only to keep Scientologists
in but to keep "wogs" out. Wogs are non-Scientologists.
In 1991 a process server tried to get onto the base. He
was beaten up and arrested by security guards who put him
in handcuffs. The Police arrived and took the handcuffs
off him saying "you guys can't do this, Man, you guys are
getting carried away. The process server later sued and
the case was settled. The security
guard, Danny Dunnigan, was so confused about what his senior
told him to testify to that he perjured himself about four
times in the Courtroom.
Chris Owen: "Ron the 'War Hero'"
However, there is absolutely no doubt that Scientology has
issued numerous inaccurate accounts of Hubbard's military
career. It has claimed that Hubbard
fought on islands which he never visited; was awarded medals
which he never won; commanded formations which never existed;
and suffered injuries which he never sustained. Some
of this can be put down to faulty research. Someone with
no nautical knowledge might not know the difference between
an armed trawler and a corvette or subchaser, for instance,
though this does not excuse a failure to check.
However, since 1979 the Church has been in possession of a complete copy of Hubbard's personnel file. Some of the more outré claims (such as that he was a Provost Marshall in Korea in 1945) have disappeared from recent biographical accounts. Others have been modified - his ships have all now been named, for instance. But other wholly untrue claims continue to be made, such as that he saw action in the North Atlantic or that he conducted secret operations ashore in the Dutch East Indies.
Lying to people to get their money isn't just unethical
- it's illegal. It's called
fraud.
Scientology claims there is a scientific basis for all their processes. There isn't. Scientology claims it's compatible with other belief systems, like Christianity. It's not. Scientology claims to be the fastest-growing religion in the world, with 8 million members, utilizing infallible technology developed by a physicist and war hero. They're lying. City of Clearwater Commission Hearing: The Church of Scientology - Day 4, LaVenda Van Schaick
MR. FLYNN:
At this time I will introduce the Affidavit of Stephen Garritano. And I'll read briefly from it. In order to save some time, I'll skip over portions of it and read the pertinent portions into the record. "My introduction to Scientology was in January of 1977 when the following representations were made to me concerning the benefits of auditing in Scientology. These representations were that auditing was scientifically guaranteed to confer the following benefits," and then there is a number of them listed which I won't read. And then there's a statement about Mr. Hubbard's background and representations and Mr. Garritano's reliance on them. "Based on the above representations, I joined the Church of Scientology. After two and-a-half years experience as a scientologist, I eventually discovered that the above representations were false and made for the single purpose to entice the people to purchase auditing and courses or join staff. Narconon Exposed: "Does Narconon work?"
There can be little doubt that the success rates found by
Gerdman's studies have seriously been misrepresented. The
Scientology publication Ron the Humanitarian states
that "Even a year after completion of the program, independent
Swedish studies found a full 84.6 percent of Narconon graduates
remaining entirely drug-free." [Narconon Sydney home page
- <http://www.drug-rehabilitation-resource.com>
and Ron the Humanitarian - <http://drugrehab.lronhubbard.org/page50.htm>]
In fact, the Gerdman study showed
that only 6.6% of Narconon Huddinge clients "remain drug-free
permanently" - if this is any way typical, it represents
a success rate only one-eleventh of that which is claimed.
Similarly, Narconon International's website states that
"61 drug abusers who graduated from Narconon Huddinge ...
[were] followed for four years after they completed the
program. Although 69 percent had been using drugs for 6
to 10 years prior to coming to the Narcononprogram [sic],
and nearly all were addicted to a multitude of different
drugs, four years later 78.6 percent were drug free." This
suggests that Gerdman managed to follow all 61 individuals,
which he did not, and that the 78.6% figure relates to the
full sample of 61, which it does not (and cannot - 78.6%
of 61 people is an impossible 47.946 people). It also does
not mention the fact that the 61 individuals represented
only 23% of the entire intake, the rest having dropped out
prior to graduation. ["Summary of Evaluations of the Narconon®
Program over the Last 30 Years", Narconon International
- <http://www.narconon.org/narconon_studies05.htm>]
In fact, it is remarkably hard to find any figures
from Narconon on what percentage of its clients manage to
graduate.
Ten days after the highly critical New York Times
report on the Church of Scientology's dodgy tax exemption,
the Church took out a full-page advertisement in the same
newspaper to rebut the charges laid against it. [...]
But the Church of Scientology catches itself in a big lie. Its statement says: "[...] The only problem: the story is untrue. No such impromptu, unscheduled meeting ever did take place." But look what David Miscavige said to 10,000 Scientologists at the Los Angeles Sports Arena on 8 October 1993, in a speech to announce the granting of tax exemption to the Church of Scientology: "[...] They asked - Fred who? We answered, Fred Goldberg of course, the Commissioner of the IRS. "Is he expecting you?" they asked. "No", was our response. "but if you phone him on the intercom and tell him we are from the Church of Scientology, I am sure he'd love to see us." [...] We did meet with the commissioner, and, as the saying goes - the rest is history." |